Effectively Managing Toxic and Other Employees with Attitude Issues

Date: July 29, 2025
Time: 01:00 PM ET
Duration: 60 Minutes
Speaker: Pete Tosh
CEU Credits : 1.0 HRCI

$0.00

Description

Many organizations occasionally encounter employees who:

  • Frequently complain or gossip
  • Use unprofessional or inappropriate language
  • Display minor acts of insubordination

 

But Toxic Employees have interpersonal styles that demonstrate a pattern of counter-productive work behaviors. While Emotionally Intelligent employees being aware of their feelings & those of others exhibit a pattern of appropriate selfmanagement.

The issue of toxic employees is more widespread than many realize. Research reveals that:

  • 95% of employees have encountered a toxic coworker, and 64% are currently working with one
  • 50% have considered quitting, and 12% actually left their job because of a toxic colleague
  • 25% have intentionally reduced their work effort due to a toxic team member
  • 20% feel targeted by toxic behavior on a weekly basis, and 10% witness such behavior daily

Toxic employees cause significant overt, covert, people-related & financial damage with their visible behavior just being the tip  of the iceberg. For example, in one organization the day a former employee left the organization is considered one of their annual holidays.

 

Why should you attend ?

Clever toxic employees often:

  • Leverage their technical skills to intimidate or manipulate others
  • Know exactly who to charm and who they can mistreat
  • Adjust their behavior to create a favorable impression when it suits them

 

Unfortunately, organizations can unintentionally enable or even reinforce toxic behavior by:

  • Restructuring roles to accommodate a toxic individual
  • Overlooking toxic behavior in employees who possess valuable skills
  • Failing to proactively seek employee input on workplace toxicity
  • Not clearly defining unacceptable interpersonal behavior or outlining the consequences for such actions

 

Managers may try to address toxicity by focusing on an employee’s attitude. While attitude plays a role in behavior, attempting to change someone’s mindset is often ineffective and unrealistic. A more effective approach for managers is to:

  • Address the specific behaviors that are harming team morale or organizational performance
  • Apply consistent positive and negative consequences to shape those behaviors

 

Session Highlights:

 

I. Human and Financial Impact of Toxic Employees

Toxic employees contribute to:

  • Disruption and needless complexity
  • Visible harm to people or processes
  • Hidden or indirect damage
  • Conflict, stress, and emotional strain
  • Declines in productivity, work quality, and overall financial performance

 

II. The A, B, C’s Related to Toxic Employees

  • Employee attitudes
  • Employee behaviors
  • Consequences that managers can exert

 

III. Understanding the Mindset of a Toxic Employee

Common Toxic Behaviors Include:

  • Exploiting their reputation or technical skills to manipulate and intimidate

  • Acting like a social chameleon—knowing exactly who to impress and who they can mistreat

  • Switching their toxic behavior on and off based on the image they want to project

  • Toxic behavior typically appears in three key forms

 

IV. Common Responses to Toxic Employees That Often Prove Ineffective

  • Adjusting the toxic employee’s role to fit their behavior
  • Allowing toxic employees to continue due to their unique skills or experience
  • Failing to actively gather employee feedback about toxic behavior in the workplace
  • Not clearly communicating to all staff which behaviors are unacceptable and the consequences that follow

 

V. Effective Strategies for Addressing and Preventing Toxicity

Organization-Wide Approaches:

  • Embedding positive interpersonal behavior as a core organizational value
  • Including interpersonal skills in performance evaluations
  • Training leaders to recognize and address toxic behavior
  • Incorporating behavior-based questions during hiring to screen out potentially toxic candidates
  • Conducting exit interviews to uncover any toxic workplace issues

 

Departmental and Team Approaches:

  • Clearly defining acceptable interpersonal behaviors with specific examples and standards
  • Using team discussions and role-playing exercises to reinforce these behavioral expectations
  • Implementing 360-degree feedback to gauge the workplace environment

 

Individual Approaches:

  • Clearly communicating which behaviors are unacceptable and explaining why
  • Describing both inappropriate and appropriate behaviors explicitly
  • Requesting the employee’s commitment to change and their plan for doing so
  • Providing frequent, focused coaching and feedback
  • Engaging executive coaches when needed
  • Applying progressive disciplinary measures
  • Proceeding with termination if necessary

 

But even terminations are not a cure-all because the:

  • Toxic-enabling people & organizational culture tendencies may remain
  • Employees may still be resentful of the way they were treated by the employee & the time it took the organization to react
  • Expertise & experience of the toxic employee are lost

 

Who should attend ?

Anyone with managerial or leadership responsibility